Author Interviews, JAMA, Mental Health Research / 02.06.2016
Study Analyzes Interventions to Reduce Compulsory Psychiatric Admissions
MedicalResearch.com Interview with:
Mark de Jong, MD, Psychiatrist
Yulius Academy, Yulius Mental Health
Barendrecht, the Netherlands
MedicalResearch.com: What is the background for this study? What are the main findings?
Response: Compulsory psychiatric admission, defined as admission against the will of the patient, has a strong effect on psychiatric patients and their relatives, and can be traumatic. Compulsory admission also conflicts with human rights, principles of autonomy, shared decision making, and recovery focused care. We also see, that rates of compulsory admissions in several European countries are tending to rise. So, interventions that prevent patients from being compulsory admitted are urgently needed.
We reviewed and meta-analyzed all currently available RCTs, that were designed to reduce compulsory admission rates in adult psychiatric patients with severe mental illnesses in outpatients settings. We found, that advance statements, like crisis plans, showed a significant 23% risk reduction in compulsory admissions. In contrast, community treatment orders and interventions for compliance enhancement showed no significant risk reduction in compulsory admissions. Although RCTs on integrated treatment showed no statistically significant risk reduction, we found a potentially clinically relevant risk reduction of 29%.
(more…)