Author Interviews, Breast Cancer, Genetic Research, UCSF / 04.09.2015
Universal BRCA Screening Not Cost-Effective Until Low-Cost Reliable Genetic Testing Available
MedicalResearch.com Interview with:
Dr. Elisa Long PhD
Assistant professor
UCLA Anderson School of Management
Medical Research: What is the background for this study? What are the main findings?
Dr. Long: The study was motivated by my own diagnosis of triple-negative breast cancer last year, at the age of 33. I also learned that I carried a BRCA1 mutation, despite no family history. As a patient, I would have benefitted tremendously from a universal BRCA screening program, but as a health services researcher, I had to ask if indiscriminate screening of all women in the U.S.—where only 1 in 400 carry a mutation—is a good use of resources.
Using a previously published decision analytic model, we calculated the cost-effectiveness of universal BRCA screening. We find that compared to screening based on family history, it is not cost-effective, assuming a test price of $2,000 to $4,000. However, as the price of genetic testing continues to fall, as indicated by the $249 test now offered by Color Genomics, universal BRCA screening becomes much more affordable. Additionally, population screening of Ashkenazi Jewish women—among whom 1 in 50 carry a BRCA mutation—is very cost-effective, because the chances of finding a carrier are much higher.
(more…)